Nic Nemeth Reveals Real Reason Behind His WWE Return at MSG

TLDR

Nic Nemeth revealed he had previously turned down multiple WWE return offers before agreeing to his November 17, 2025 RAW appearance at Madison Square Garden, stating he only came back because it was specifically for John Cena's "Last Time Is Now" tournament. Speaking on the Pro Wrestling Podcast, Nemeth explained that once WWE framed the return around helping Cena's farewell run and their shared history together, the decision became easy, though he emphasized he has no interest in returning to WWE full-time.