Jonathan Coachman’s WWE Return: Why It’s Unlikely

One big thing: Jonathan Coachman is reluctant to return to WWE

Former WWE personality Jonathan Coachman has expressed hesitation about returning to the company, citing past issues and a changing landscape.

• “No, I do not want to go back,” Coachman stated on “Insight with Chris Van Vliet.”
• He acknowledged being open to discussions but highlighted problems from his 2018 return.
• Coachman criticized the three-man commentary team structure and his perceived role as an outsider.

Why it matters

Coachman’s reluctance reflects broader changes in WWE’s talent management and broadcasting approach since Vince McMahon’s departure.

The details

Coachman’s 2018 return

• He felt constrained by Vince McMahon’s directive to maintain his ESPN journalist credibility.
• Coachman believed this prevented him from portraying his “heel Coach” persona, which he considers his best version.

Commentary team issues

• Coachman struggled in a three-person setup with Michael Cole and Cory Graves.
• He noted a lack of chemistry with Graves, stating they barely got to know each other.

Changing WWE policies

• Coachman faced consequences for attending pre-scheduled golfing events during his WWE tenure.
• He contrasted this with WWE’s current flexibility, allowing Pat McAfee to work on ESPN’s “College GameDay” for months.

The bottom line

While Coachman isn’t completely closing the door on WWE, his past experiences and the company’s evolving policies make a return unlikely in the near future.

What do you think about WWE’s changing approach to talent management? Do you believe it’s for the better? Share your thoughts in the comments below.